How Does SecurityScorecard Work?

Security ratings are a resourceful metric that provides a gauge on the external cybersecurity posture of organizations and has become a data point that is important in today’s digital landscape, as businesses strive to protect their sensitive data and assets from cyberattacks. One of the original providers of security rating services is SecurityScorecard, which offers a platform for assessing and improving an organization’s cybersecurity posture for both enterprise risk and third-party risk management use cases. But how exactly does it work? 

How does SecurityScorecard get its data?

SecurityScorecard Dashboard UI, source: securityscorecard.com 

The platform utilizes a combination of external and proprietary data sources, continuously monitoring a myriad of risk factors. The platform collects data from a variety of sources, including public records, vulnerability scans, threat intelligence and breach history ensuring an external view of an organization’s cybersecurity posture made available to clients and organization’s assessing companies as vendors. SecurityScorecard then analyzes this data to generate a security rating for the enterprise or each vendor organization being evaluated. 

SecurityScorecard gathers data from a variety of sources, including: 

  • Publicly available information: Security Scorecard scans the internet for information about an organization’s security posture, such as exposed ports, outdated software, and known vulnerabilities. 
  • Private data sources: SecurityScorecard also integrates data from a variety of private sources, such as security researchers, threat intelligence feeds, and vulnerability databases. 

Read the Whitepaper

The Evolution of Cybersecurity Ratings and How They Can Boost Risk Visibility

What is the SecurityScorecard scale?

SecurityScorecard gathers data from external sources but emphasizes publicly accessible information, focusing on factors like DNS health and patching cadence. SecurityScorecard can also directly scan organizations to help reduce the misattributions of IT asset ownerships to organizations. 

SecurityScorecard evaluates an organization’s cybersecurity posture across across ten groups of risk factors, including DNS health, IP reputation, web application security, network security, leaked information, hacker chatter, endpoint security, and patching cadence, as described on their website. 

They take into account all the external-facing discoverable assets of an organization, the issues associated with those assets, and the severity of the threats that were found in order to determine a score for each organization. The scores are graded and measured along a cybersecurity risk rating scale in this case the SecurityScorecard scale is on an alpha scale of A-F. 

Is SecurityScorecard worth it?

Ultimately, whether or not SecurityScorecard is worth it for an organization depends on its specific needs, challenges and budget. Other things to consider are the methodologies used to derive the security rating, dispute process for any misattributions or false positives and their customer support experience. There are publicly available references that also discuss ‘Is SecurityScorecard worth it?’ that can be found Reddit SecurityScorecard forums, Gartner Peer Insights, G2 reviews and so on. 

SecurityScorecard offers a number of benefits for organizations, including: 

  • Improved visibility into security risks: SecurityScorecard provides an overview of an organization’s security posture based on what it can identify for assets, that will then include any strengths and weaknesses of those attributed assets (remember the need for accuracy and misattributions from earlier). This can help organizations to identify and prioritize their security risks. 
  • Enhanced decision-making: SecurityScorecard’s data can be used to make informed decisions about cybersecurity investments and initiatives. 
  • Reduced costs: By identifying and addressing external security risks early, organizations can save money on security incidents and data breaches that may be sourced from an external perspective. 
  • Competitive advantage: A good security rating can give organizations a competitive advantage in the marketplace like when they are being evaluated as a potential vendor (where the client wants a low cyber risk provider as judged by the provided security rating) or seeking lower cyber insurance premiums.

However, there are also some potential drawbacks to using SecurityScorecard, such as: 

  • Cost: SecurityScorecard can be expensive, there may be tangential costs related to an inaccurate rating and the dispute process may not be swift, especially for small businesses. 
  • Accuracy: SecurityScorecard’s ratings are based on a variety of factors, and there is always a risk that they may not be completely accurate. 
  • Reliance on external data: SecurityScorecard’s ratings are based on data from external sources, which can be inaccurate or incomplete. 

 

As businesses weigh their options in cybersecurity threat assessment tools and security ratings providers, evaluating the competition is crucial. Several SecurityScorecard competitors compete in the market, offering alternative solutions. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of SecurityScorecard compared to SecurityScorecard competitors is essential for making an informed decision. 

SecurityScorecard competitors include: 

  • BitSight 
  • Black Kite 
  • CyberGRX 
  • FortifyData 
  • Panorays 
  • Prevelant 
  • RiskRecon 
  • Upguard 

How does FortifyData work?

FortifyData is an alternative to SecurityScorecard and other security ratings providers that provides a more trusted and accurate security rating, according to clients. FortifyData is an automated threat assessment platform that produces a security rating that results from conducting threat exposure analysis and more comprehensive vulnerability assessments.

The FortifyData security rating is based on weekly direct and comprehensive, but non-intrusive, assessments of external IT assets which are confirmed by the client. Read more about how we calculate security ratings in our publicly available security rating methodology. 

What other security ratings vendors don’t provide but FortifyData does, is the ability to classify the identified assets based on business impact and allows for likelihood of risk scenario adjustments to produce a contextualized security rating. This same approach is conducted for enterprise risk management and third-party risk management. 

Additionally, FortifyData provides the option to also conduct internal risk assessments to add to the cyber security rating, so you truly get a comprehensive security rating based on external and internal information. 

This alternative security ratings approach results in a more accurate and up-to-date security rating that FortifyData clients say is more trusted. 

How accurate is the SecurityScorecard rating?

The accuracy of the SecurityScorecard rating is a complex issue. The SecurityScorecard rating uses a proprietary algorithm to generate its security rating, and the company does not disclose all of the factors that are considered. However, SecurityScorecard security rating services has been independently validated by a number of third-party organizations, and its ratings have been found to be useful. 

The accuracy of a security rating services system is a critical consideration for businesses. SecurityScorecard employs advanced algorithms and continuously updates its data to provide an accurate reflection of an organization’s security posture. However, like any system, it has its limitations. Exploring the nuances of SecurityScorecard’s rating system allows organizations to grasp the precision and reliability of the scores provided. 

How does SecurityScorecard work?

The security rating from SecurityScorecard, like many other security rating services providers, is produced by: 

  • Collecting data: SecurityScorecard collects data from a variety of sources, as described above. 
  • Analyzing data: SecurityScorecard analyzes the data to identify security risks and vulnerabilities. 
  • Generating security ratings: SecurityScorecard generates a security rating for each organization based on its analysis of the data. 
  • Providing insights: SecurityScorecard provides organizations with insights into their security posture and recommendations for improvement. 

How does SecurityScorecard collect data?

At the core of SecurityScorecard’s functionality is its reliance on a range of risk and vulnerability data to provide their security rating services. These data points contribute valuable insights, ranging from network security to application security and breach history. SecurityScorecard collects data using a variety of methods, including: 

  • Scanning the internet: SecurityScorecard continuously scans the internet for information about an organization’s security posture. 
  • Analyzing data feeds: SecurityScorecard collects data from a variety of data feeds, such as security researchers and threat intelligence feeds. 
  • Integrating with other security tools: SecurityScorecard can integrate with other security tools to collect additional data. 

Now You Know the Answer to How Does SecurityScorecard Work?

SecurityScorecard is one of the original security rating providers that can help organizations to improve their cybersecurity posture. However, it is important to understand the limitations of the platform and to use it in conjunction with other security measures. 

In conclusion, this article aims to demystify the question, “How does SecurityScorecard work?” By examining its data collection methods, assessing its worth in comparison to competitors, gauging the accuracy of its ratings, and understanding the collaboration with security rating services, businesses can make informed decisions about integrating SecurityScorecard into their cybersecurity arsenal. 

Try Security Ratings from FortifyData

FortifyData provides a trusted and accurate security rating based on weekly external attack surface assessments of your confirmed IT asset inventory. We take into account asset classification, likelihood adjustments and compensating controls and enrich the findings with dark web discoveries and cyber threat intelligence to give you a contextualized security rating.

FortifyData is an industry-leading automated cybersecurity risk management platform that enables the enterprise to manage cyber risk across the organization. By combining automated attack surface assessments with asset classification, risk-based vulnerability management, security ratings and third-party risk management, you get an all-in-one cyber risk management platform. 

Related Resources